labradore

"We can't allow things that are inaccurate to stand." — The Word of Our Dan, February 19, 2008.

Monday, February 26, 2007

Small business, and getting smaller

The 2003 PC Party platform stated:

In this Province, medium and small businesses play the lead role in creating employment and income, and in diversifying both the products and services we sell and the markets into which we sell them.

Medium and small business are even more important to sustainable economic and social development in rural communities, since they are labour-intensive and widely dispersed throughout the Province. They are often the only realistic prospect for creating jobs and reducing unemployment.

During its first mandate, a Progressive Conservative government will formulate and implement smart policies and programs to promote medium and small business development.
How has the small business sector fared in the past four years?

Not good.

According to the provincial government's own statistics, the number of businesses in the province has declined by nearly 3% overall between the election year of 2003 and 2005, the most recent year for which statistics are available. The number declined in almost every part of the province, with the sole exception, among the 20 economic zones, of Labrador West and St. John's. This map shows the extent of the decline; green represents an increase in registered businesses; yellow a decrease of up to -5%; orange a decrease of up to -10%; red a decrease of -10% or more. (Click to enlarge.)

In the first two full years of Danny Williams' government, 2003 through 2005 inclusive, the number of registered businesses decreased for two years running in the province overall. The decline was widespread, exhibiting itself in twelve out of twenty zones.

And in the five years up to and including 2005, a pre-census year, the number of businesses in the province declined by nearly -5%.

(In fairness, the year-over-year change for 2004-2005, the most recent figures available, was positive in northern, central, and western Labrador, and in St. John's, which has only had a year-over-year business decline in one year (2002) for which figures are available.)

If — and it's a somewhat of an "if", but not a huge "if" — this business decline corresponds even approximately to the population change over the same period, then the 2006 census of population, due out in just over two weeks, will probably reveal a province whose population, which stood at 512,000 in 2001, has slumped back below half a million, to the population it had in the mid- to late 1960s.

7 Comments:

At 1:59 PM, February 26, 2007 , Blogger jon_ said...

How do you come to the conclusion that this is bad or good? Maybe we've had a false economy over the past years and its correcting itself. Wouldn't this be a good thing?

 
At 4:10 PM, February 26, 2007 , Blogger Erik Sorenson said...

Losing small businesses is never a "good thing".

 
At 12:31 AM, February 27, 2007 , Blogger WJM said...

I'd tend to agree with Erik Sorenson, but I know where you are coming from, jon_ ... the only thing is that I have seen no empirical evidence of such an economic correction.

It would be nice to think that the decline of business enterprise figure outside St. John's and Labrador West is, if it has to happen, merely the result of a fundamental change in the nature of the economy.

Instead, the figures I've seen, at least down to 2004, show an economy that is MORE dependent than ever on federal and provincial public-service salaries and transfers to individuals, and federal transfers payments... not less.

The economy is actually becoming "falser", and in fact if the later pre-2004 trend continues to today, the amount of personal income earned in NL through non-government market sources probably now accounts for less than half of the total. Public-sector salaries and transfers to individuals were already pushing 50% of the total three years ago, and the trendline wasn't pretty.

And since then, we've had Comrade Williams scare several large billions worth of private industry out of the province.

The day of reckoning is going to be ugly throughout the political-economic spectrum.

 
At 6:07 AM, February 27, 2007 , Blogger Brian said...

Atlantic Wholesalers are closing in Lewisport, 74 jobs gone. Not to mention the effect on Labrador.

Take the federal money out of Coastal Labrador, bingo you got the Ethiopia of the north.

 
At 2:51 PM, February 27, 2007 , Blogger jon_ said...

Can you point me to the figures re:income? I thought we were losing federal jobs here, not gaining? Or is the jump in government dependence just a percentage gain because of the loss in small business...

Are Atlantic Wholesalers moving to St. John's?

 
At 3:11 PM, February 27, 2007 , Blogger WJM said...

Can you point me to the figures re:income?

It's from Statscan tables that you have to buy, sadly.

I thought we were losing federal jobs here, not gaining?

A) It depends on where your starting point is. Yes, the number of federal jobs is down compared to the late 1980s/early 1990s when Crosbie and Mulroney were bloating the civil service to record levels to curry regional favour. But the period of decline ended in 1998; since 1999 the trendline has been UPWARDS, not downwards.

The Harris Centre, Danny Williams, et al. always compare today to 1991, thereby glossing over the recent trendline.

B) Federal jobs are only one part of the non-private income picture. The provincial public sector has grown much faster than the federal one. Both federal and provincial transfers to individuals are also substantial sums of money as well.

Or is the jump in government dependence just a percentage gain because of the loss in small business...

The amount of public-sector personal income has been growing recently in both absolute and relative terms. Conservely, private-sector personal income has been declining in both absolute and relative terms.

Are Atlantic Wholesalers moving to St. John's?

According to the news today, eys.

 
At 3:25 PM, February 27, 2007 , Blogger Mark said...

jon - WJM makes a good point about the biased analysis of the # of federal jobs. Another thing that is often overlooked is that the biggest single drop in federal empolyees in the province occurred when the services at the Goose Bay base were privatized in the early 90s. On paper it appears to be a larger reduction than it really was, because many of the jobs stayed on the base, they just weren't public servants any more.

As for the Harris centre, it is useful to keep in mind who "sponsors" their reports, and when they time their "release". Dig a little and you may find a few unseemly coincidences...

 

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home